|
Post by pacino on Feb 5, 2014 13:04:18 GMT -5
Going to the store after work to pick it up...any feedback as of yet?
|
|
michaelk
Fearless Defender
So many comics, so little time.
Posts: 41
|
Post by michaelk on Feb 5, 2014 13:46:24 GMT -5
I thought it was a good first issue. Alphona and his colorist nail the visuals, it looks great. Wilson fills the story with a lot of cultural references that really define this character as a non-traditional mainstream comics protagonist. I liked it, though I also felt there was a lot of information all at once. I have several (pretty liberal) Muslim friends so some of the stuff I understood (and laughed at) right away, and I'm willing to take some time to get comfortable with the writer's tone and approach to fill in the blanks on things I didn't immediately understand. We get to meet the supporting cast quickly, and while I liked the dialogue and the banter, I thought there were some borderline stereotypes being over-exploited. We'll see. There's a young adult approach to this story which I think will serve it well as long as Wilson and her team can challenge some of the trope's stereotypes. As of right now, I trust her and I'm looking forward to this character's growth.
|
|
|
Post by wjohnson22 on Feb 5, 2014 23:57:30 GMT -5
I thought it was a good first issue. Alphona and his colorist nail the visuals, it looks great. Wilson fills the story with a lot of cultural references that really define this character as a non-traditional mainstream comics protagonist. I liked it, though I also felt there was a lot of information all at once. I have several (pretty liberal) Muslim friends so some of the stuff I understood (and laughed at) right away, and I'm willing to take some time to get comfortable with the writer's tone and approach to fill in the blanks on things I didn't immediately understand. We get to meet the supporting cast quickly, and while I liked the dialogue and the banter, I thought there were some borderline stereotypes being over-exploited. We'll see. There's a young adult approach to this story which I think will serve it well as long as Wilson and her team can challenge some of the trope's stereotypes. As of right now, I trust her and I'm looking forward to this character's growth. I think this is a great assessment. I thought it was a very charming first issue. It would be hard to avoid any pitfalls when trying to introduce religious and cultural traditions many reads aren't familiar with in 20 pages. Overall, I think G. Willow Wilson does a good job of showing Kamala as an authentic human being. On the one hand, she wants to be accepted and fit in, on the other hand, she doesn't want to completely shed her cultural heritage. For me, what works is that nothing in issue seems like a gimmick, and seeds are planted for what is sure to be an ongoing identity struggle for Kamala. Many people can relate to Kamala's struggle in terms of how to find our own identity amidst pressure from parents, peers, and society. I'm definitely excited to see where this series goes.
|
|
|
Post by joestate on Feb 6, 2014 1:50:17 GMT -5
I bought a physical copy of this today just because I was already grabbing the punisher and I thought it felt important. Also the teaser in the all new marvel now book got me interested as well. I find the character very fun and interesting, her supporting cast is great as well. I will absolutely be going on to the next issue.
Can I just take a second to mention that the little angel sloth thing iron man was carrying was adorable? I want one for a pet
|
|
|
Post by Almeida77 on Feb 6, 2014 7:57:11 GMT -5
I thin it was the perfect example of how a #1 should be done. All your main cast and supporting introduced the basic set up of her "normal life" before throwing her into the unknown, establishing her personality so well and showing she has a rebellious streak akin to her idol and it was damn funny.
I totally forgot I was reading a Marvel book which was to its strength. Even down the the way the panels were constructed and lined just felt like those in charge at Marvel really let them do whatever the hell they wanted to do and it turned out amazingly. The best thing about the issue though was it humour and though you all seem a little uneasy or unable to understand the "cultural" aspects displayed thats where I found the best chuckles. I know probably as much as ya'll about being Muslim but you don't need to know anything to read this its all there. Its in the way they interact not what they are saying.
Anyway, book of the week without a doubt
|
|
|
Post by pacino on Feb 6, 2014 9:31:23 GMT -5
I've yet to read my copy, but I noticed it was $3 with a free digital...is that a first??? I gave my copy away to my friend to let him check it out. I wonder if that's what they're going for.
|
|
|
Post by joroak on Feb 6, 2014 13:01:04 GMT -5
I picked this up because I'd heard so much about it. I like the fact it doesn't shy away from the religion aspect of the book. I'll be picking this up
|
|
|
Post by rcbtaw on Feb 6, 2014 17:08:56 GMT -5
Looking for a book (ongoing series) for my 11 year old daughter. I already have it pulled at my store, but I was wondering if you all thought it is appropriate for my daughter. She read the first 10 or so Issues of Supergirl in the new 52. She has read Li'l Gotham as we'll. Thanks for the input.
|
|
|
Post by Bob Reyer on Feb 6, 2014 18:44:52 GMT -5
Looking for a book (ongoing series) for my 11 year old daughter. I already have it pulled at my store, but I was wondering if you all thought it is appropriate for my daughter. She read the first 10 or so Issues of Supergirl in the new 52. She has read Li'l Gotham as we'll. Thanks for the input. Christian, I would say that Ms. Marvel is certainly appropriate, with the one caveat that within the story, Kamala disobeys her family and sneaks out to a party where there are boys and alcohol. She doesn't indulge in either, but I'd rather point it out just in case! I think that your daughter will love it, by the way!
|
|
|
Post by rcbtaw on Feb 6, 2014 19:55:27 GMT -5
Thanks Bob! Your recommendations are golden. Let's just hope for our sakes that your enjoyment of this book doesn't sentence it to the comics phantom zone! HA HA!
|
|
|
Post by courtneyk on Feb 6, 2014 20:22:22 GMT -5
I adored this book. As I said in my introduction post I'm fairly new to comics, especially superhero ones, and the fact that this is a heroine who's from a very different background and perspective than any of the comics characters I've been familiar with through pop culture was appealing to me. I liked Kamala's voice - I also enjoy reading young adult novels so this having a bit of a young adult vibe to it as michaelk mentioned was a plus. I'm really looking forward to the next issue.
|
|
|
Post by Czor on Feb 6, 2014 20:31:02 GMT -5
Love this issue! I like how is so balanced in it's use of religion/ethnicity that is not hitting you with it. Also I loved the hedgehog with the Hulk hands in Kamala's dream sequence.
|
|
|
Post by Bob Reyer on Feb 6, 2014 21:23:40 GMT -5
Thanks Bob! Your recommendations are golden. Let's just hope for our sakes that your enjoyment of this book doesn't sentence it to the comics phantom zone! HA HA! Christian, Let's not even joke about that! Ms. Marvel was so good, it will be immune to even my enjoyment of it!
|
|
|
Post by Bob Reyer on Feb 6, 2014 21:27:25 GMT -5
I adored this book. As I said in my introduction post I'm fairly new to comics, especially superhero ones, and the fact that this is a heroine who's from a very different background and perspective than any of the comics characters I've been familiar with through pop culture was appealing to me. I liked Kamala's voice - I also enjoy reading young adult novels so this having a bit of a young adult vibe to it as michaelk mentioned was a plus. I'm really looking forward to the next issue. Courtney, That's a great point about the "Young Adult" angle that you and Michael bring up! If Marvel can get the word around, that would be a new market for this title, particularly down the road when the trade comes out!
|
|
|
Post by JediHunter66 on Feb 6, 2014 21:28:08 GMT -5
One of my favorite moments was 3 panels in, "Chow or chow not, there is no smell." Star Wars references are the key to my heart.
|
|